UFAS/ADA Issues Caused by Reasonable Accommodations

Reasonable Accommodations That Create ADA/UFAS Issues (Additional Parking Spaces)

This summer we have noticed a trend while on-site doing either Capital Needs Assessments or UPCS (Pre-REAC) Inspections. Some well-intentioned managers and property administrators are adding "accessible design" features because a tenant requests a reserved parking space or a space that is closer to their unit or entrance. In order to accommodate the tenant's request, property managers are adding a "universal symbol" sign to another parking space (in addition to their 5% set aside) to accommodate the request but not actually converting the space to an "ADA Accessible Space".

There are a few elements that are often found to be wrong in this situation – most commonly are the physical errors when creating an "accessible space" that make the space out of compliance with ADA/UFAS/Section 504 requirements.

  • Spaces should be 96" wide with a 60" access aisle
  • The sign in front of the parking stall must be mounted high enough to be seen while a vehicle is in the space (typically more than 60")
  • Maximum Slope of 1:50 in all directions
  • The parking space and access aisle must be completely free of any obstructions

The issue that we are seeing is that to respond to the reasonable accommodation request, managers are adding the "sign" but not meeting any of the other requirements. In doing so, they are inadvertently creating a non-compliance with ADA requirements, as well as UPCS (Blocked or damaged accessible route), and Section 504.

What Should I Do Instead?

Assuming that you have already met your requirement for handicapped parking elsewhere on your property, consider the alternatives. In most cases, a "Reserved" or "Private" parking sign will accommodate the request without actually letting loose the Pandora's box of requirements that come with using the "universal access" sign. Remember that once you use the "universal access" sign, requirements under ADA, UFAS, and local codes (depending on the state) all become applicable, and are governed by the Civil Rights Division of the Department of Justice. In short – this is a very different thing than Mrs. Smith in Apartment 4D asking for her own parking spot.

You can view the rules for Parking Striping from the DOJ here.

We have also included a series of photos on our site to illustrate this issue.

If you should have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact us with questions about training, issues with ADA, UFAS, or UPCS Compliance - please do not hesitate to
click here let us know.

HUD HOME Program to use UPCS Protocol
HOME Program Inspection Rules

Latest Blogs

13 January 2020
REAC Inspections
Resident Involvement in REAC/NSPIRE Inspection Process​​As part of the NSPIRE pilot process, HUD has announced that additional processes will be added to engage the residents in the REAC/NSPIRE process. You can read the press release on HUD's website...
24 August 2019
REAC Inspections
On August 21, 2019, HUD published a set of proposed rules in the Federal Register "Notice of Demonstration To Assess the National Standards for the Physical Inspection of Real Estate and Associated Protocols" 24 CFR Parts 5 and 200; [Docket No. FR–6...
21 August 2019
REAC Inspections
On August 20, 2019, HUD released the first of the new NSPIRE protocols which will be expected to become active once the pilot/demonstration program has concluded. This is a first look at what deficiencies will look like under NSPIRE, the inspection ...
16 July 2019
REAC Inspections
July 8, 2019 HUD's Office of Multifamily Housing Asset Management and Oversight released a memorandum reiterating the rules surrounding notice prior to entering resident's units, availability of documentation for residents to review, and clarificati...
09 July 2019
REAC Inspections
The House Financial Services Committee passed a bill - the Safe Housing for Families Act of 2019 (H.R. 1690), and it will likely move forward to a full vote in the near future. The bill provides $300 million over three years to fund the installation...

Blog Archive